EN 388 vs ANSI/ISEA 105: Understanding the Key Differences in Hand Protection Safety Standards
BLOG ARTICLES
When it comes to evaluating the protection levels of work gloves, two major industry standards are recognized worldwide: ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 and EN 388:2016.
The ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 standard, developed by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and the International Safety Equipment Association (ISEA), is the U.S. standard for hand protection. More broad in application, EN 388:2016 is the European standard used internationally. Both standards assess cut, abrasion, puncture, and tear resistance, but they are not directly comparable due to their different testing methodologies and classification systems.
Glove Markings and Classification Systems
Each standard utilizes a structured classification system and rigorous testing procedure to ensure that gloves meet specific safety and performance criteria. It is important to understand the classification systems for both standards, as many work gloves will show both marketing on the wrist or back of the hand. ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 provides numeric levels for resistance, while EN 388: 2016 incorporates both numerical ratings and letter grades, offering a comprehensive view of glove protection. By examining these standards, users can gain insights into their similarities and differences, helping to make informed decisions about the most suitable hand protection for various tasks and applications.
ANSI/ISEA 105-2016
The ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 standard is a widely recognized benchmark for assessing the performance of protective work gloves in the United States. This standard focuses on providing clear and separate testing classifications for various types of resistance, ensuring that gloves meet specific safety and performance criteria for different industrial and occupational hazards.
Separate Markings: The standard has distinct markings for cut, abrasion, and puncture resistance, each tested separately
Classification Levels: Features nine cut levels and five abrasion and puncture levels
Identification: Each level is represented by a unique shield with the protection level indicated numerically, where the higher the number rating indicates the higher the level of protection
Exclusions: Has a separate standard for Impact Resistance (ANSI/ISEA 138-2019)
EN 388: 2016
The EN 388:2016 standard is commonly used for evaluating the protective qualities of gloves, not only in Europe but also gloves sold in North America, Australia, and New Zealand. It offers comprehensive testing and rating for multiple types of mechanical hazards, providing users with reliable information about the gloves' performance in various protective categories.
Marking Presence: Commonly found on cut-resistant and non-cut-resistant gloves sold in North America.
Third-Party Testing: Gloves are tested by third party ISO labs for cut, abrasion, puncture, tear, and impact resistance.
Two Cut Ratings: Includes a Coup Test with five numerical levels and a TDM-100 Test (added in 2016) with letter grades A-F for more accurate cut resistance.
Impact Resistance: The impact test is optional and applies only to gloves claiming back-of-the-hand protection. Ratings are P (Pass), F (Fail), or X (not tested).
PIP® has been testing all gloves to both ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 and EN 388:2016 since 2005, offering several advantages to ensure comprehensive protection across various environments and workplace hazards:
- Advanced safety and performance
- Varied testing approaches to assure reliability
- Market versatility and compliance to reach a wider acceptance
- Differentiation to gain competitive edge
Comparing the Testing Methods
Both ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 and EN 388:2016 use various methods to evaluate glove performance, though they differ in their approach.
Abrasion |
| ANSI 105-2016 |
| Taber Test |
| The Taber Test involves securing the test fabric on a rotating disc while two wheels with a 180 grit abradant, such as emery board or sandpaper, rub the fabric in a circular motion. The number of cycles that the fabric can endure before its shows noticeable wear determines the abrasion rating on a 1-6 scale. This method is the most favored due to the wide range of materials it can evaluate. |
|
EN 388:2016 |
Martindale Test |
| The Martindale Test uses a similar rotating disc to the Taber Test but rubs the fabric in a figure-eight motion. The number of cycles that the fabric can endure before it shows noticeable wear determines the abrasion rating. |
|
Cut |
ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 |
TDM-100 Test |
| The sample is cut by a straight-edge blade, under a specific weight load that moves along a straight path. The sample is cut five times at three different weight loads, referred to as a cutting force, with a new size blade -- short, medium, and long -- for each load, providing 15 data-points. The cutting force is then used to determine the appropriate cut level. |
|
EN 388:2016 |
TDM-100 TestCoup Test |
| The Coup Test is conducted using a circular blade that rotates in cycles and moves back and forth along the same piece of material until the material is cut through. The test uses the same amount of force on all samples. Materials that achieve a higher cut score will contribute to the dulling of the blade. |
|
Tear |
ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 |
|
Tear testing is not specifically called out under the ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 standard. |
|
EN 388:2016 |
|
Tear Resistance Test |
|
The EN388 Tear Resistance Test is measured by testing the tensile strength of a glove by applying force to four separate tear points on the fabric. The force is increased until the material is torn. The amount of force used to tear the material is recorded and categorized on a 1-4 scale. |
|
Puncture |
| ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 |
| Blunt Puncture Test |
|
The Blunt Force Puncture Testing uses a 4.5mm probe, resembling a ballpoint pen, at a 90-degree angle to simulate a tear or burst hazard. The test measures the amount of force needed for a blunt probe to pierce through PPE material at a rate of 100mm per minute. |
|
| EN 388:2016 |
| Blunt Puncture Test |
|
The Blunt Force Puncture Testing uses a 4.5mm probe, resembling a ballpoint pen, at a 90-degree angle to simulate a tear or burst hazard. The test measures the amount of force needed for a blunt probe to pierce through PPE material at a rate of 100mm per minute. |
|
Impact |
ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 |
|
Impact Resistance is testing under a separate standard: ANSI/ISEA 138-2019 |
EN 388:2016 |
Impact Resistance Test |
|
The sample is cut open and laid out flat over a raised anvil. A 2.5kg striker force is dropped on the knuckles at an impact force of 5 joules. If the average transmitted force is less than or equal to 7kN, the gloves will be marked P for Pass. If the average transmitted force is higher than 9kN, the gloves will be marked F for Fail. Gloves that have not been tested will be marked X. |
|
Navigating ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 and EN 388:2016 for Optimal Hand Protection
Selecting the right work gloves for your specific needs can make all the difference in ensuring safety and performance on the job. With the complexities of ANSI/ISEA 105-2016 and EN 388:2016, understanding these standards is crucial for making informed decisions.
Our team of hand protection experts are available to help you navigate these standards and find the best solutions for your safety requirements. Contact us for a personalized assessment and tailored recommendations to ensure you choose the perfect work gloves for your needs.
MORE ARTICLES
Spotlight on Safety - Trends from NSC Safety Congress & Expo
Last September, safety professionals worldwide gathered in Orlando, FL, for the NSC Safety Congress & Expo, where the latest industry advancements and ideas took center stage. Our team arrived wi…
READ MORENitrile vs. Latex Coated Gloves – Which is the Best For Your Workforce?
When it comes to choosing work gloves, selecting the right coating can make all the difference in safety, comfort and performance. Nitrile and latex coatings both offer unique benefits, making them su…
READ MORE4 Hidden Jobsite Risks - And How To Avoid Them
Nearly five million workers currently make up the American construction industry. That includes laborers, carpenters, trade and extraction workers, site managers and others. While it may not be apparent fr…
READ MOREExperience Barrier Protection and Flexibility With Extended Use Gloves
Barrier glove technology has changed dramatically over the last 10 years as glove demand has increased. Gone are the days when rough hands or stained fingers defined what we did for a living. Today, ev…
READ MOREThe Evolution of Hand Protection: Advancements, Challenges and Future Directions
Hand protection has seen significant advancements in the past five years, driven by the need to reduce hand injuries and enhance worker safety across various industries. With evolving technologies and ma…
READ MOREConstruction Hand Protection 101: Spotting and Mitigating Risks
In construction, hands are everything – they’re essential for every task, whether it’s operating heavy machinery, handling materials or doing precision work. Protecting them isn’t ju…
READ MOREHow D3O®iP™ Technology Is Setting A New Standard For Hand Protection
Impact-related hand injuries are the most common occupational hazards in the industrial work force. According to a study conducted by the U.S. Department of Labor between 2021-2022, 23 percent of all work-rel…
READ MOREEnhancing Workplace Safety in the Construction Industry with Multi-Directional Head Protection Technology
It’s no surprise that workers in the construction industry are at a high risk of accidents; the industry consistently ranks as one of the most dangerous in the U.S. The causes of workplace injuries have…
READ MOREUnraveling The Dynamics of ESD Safety
When it comes to Electrostatic Discharge (ESD) Safety, it’s all about control – static control. The ESD Association® sets many of the global standards that are considered guiding principles for static con…
READ MORESpecialized PPE For Electric Vehicle Manufacturing
For years, the United States has been the second largest manufacturer of motor vehicles, manufacturing over 1.5 million cars and 7.6 million commercial vehicles annually due largely to leading companies li…
READ MORESurviving the Summer Heat: A Guide to Workplace Safety and Hydration
With rising temperatures comes an increased risk of heat-related illnesses. These conditions arise when the body struggles to maintain its internal temperature due to excessive heat exposure, leading to p…
READ MOREThe Importance of Providing Proper Fitting PPE For Women
Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is vital in ensuring worker safety across all trade industries. However, when PPE doesn't fit correctly, it can be just as dangerous as not wearing any protection at…
READ MOREProtective Gear for TIG Welding
For starters, April is National Welding Month. PIP USA appreciates all the hard-working welders of America. For those familiar with welding, the terms heliarc welding, tungsten inert gas welding o…
READ MOREWhat to Consider When Choosing High-Visibility Multi-Season Workwear
Winter and Spring can be a hazardous time of year for people who work outdoors. That's why companies must train their employees on how to stay safe while also providing them with the proper protective eq…
READ MOREMotor Vehicle Manufacturing: Supporting A Successful Safety Program
The Automotive industry, a pillar of America’s economic strength, continues to demonstrate steady growth with rising employment numbers. According to the BLS, employment within the motor vehicles an…
READ MOREMulti-task Welding Gloves Offer The Protection And Dexterity Welders Need
If you’re well-versed with the welding trade, you’ll know that a welder spends the majority of their time not necessarily welding. In fact, welders only spend approximately 25% of th…
READ MOREWhy Welders Need Cut-Resistant Gloves
Hand injuries are among the most common workplace injuries, with over a third involving lacerations. It's not hard to understand why, after all, hands are often closest in proximity to workplace hazards. Th…
READ MORESafety Helmets with Mips® Offer Protection from Linear and Rotational Impacts
Head protection has come a long way since the day of the “Hard-Boiled Hat” which made its appearance in the early 1920s to protect members of the U.S. Navy and coastal shipyard workers from im…
READ MORESustainable Solutions in PPE
Sustainable, eco-friendly, biodegradable… We can go on and on. Every day, we are bombarded with product alternatives that claim to be better for the environment – almost to the point that it…
READ MOREA Welder's Guide to Avoiding Cold Related Injury and Illness
Extreme cold weather is a dangerous situation that can bring on health emergencies and welders working in cold environments are no exception to this. All workers who are exposed to extreme cold are at ris…
READ MOREThe Psychology Behind Effective Food Safety Culture
What’s the first thing you think of when you see a firefighter helmet? If your answer was hero, rescue, save, protect or first responder, you’d be in line with the majority of Americans. The…
READ MOREUnderstanding The Differences Between Antimicrobial, Antiviral and Antibacterial Hand Protection
ANTIMICROBIAL - ANTIVIRAL - ANTIBACTERIAL: What Does This All Mean for Hand Protection? by Anthony Di Giovanni, Vice President of Global Marketing Safety managers are demanding PPE tha…
READ MOREReusable vs. Disposable – Using The Right Garment For The Right Job
Disposable garments or reusable garments – which choice is right for you? There has always been back-and-forth about whether reusable or disposable garments are best for the wo…
READ MORETop 3 Trending Safety Solutions in Construction
According to OSHA, the continuously evolving construction industry accounts for one in five worker fatalities across all private industries. It is crucial to stay vigilant and take the best safety precautions available when facing the multiple hazards present on a construction job site. …
READ MOREHeat Resistant Gloves Are A Hot Topic
Customers often ask us, “What do you mean by ‘light heat resistance’ with these gloves (or sleeves)?” Whether consciously or not – they are looking for some sort of assurance th…
READ MOREWhat is Double Hearing Protection and When Would You Need It?
You might be asking yourself if double hearing protection is something you should be considering. In order to understand what double hearing protection is, let’s start by reviewing why it is nee…
READ MORE6 Key Facts to Help Understand ARC Flash Risks
There are few things no utility worker wants to experience – ARC flash is one of them. The phenomenon is described as a sudden, bright, blinding light and heat that occurs because of a rapid relea…
READ MORE3 Common Types of Cold Stress - And How You Can Prepare For Them
Whether we're ready or not, winter will be here before we know it. Now is the perfect time to start planning ahead to stay prepared. No matter what winter throws your way—whether it's blizzards, fr…
READ MOREANSI/ISEA 138-2019 Classification For Impact Resistant Gloves Helps Decrease Back-Of-The-Hand Injuries
Impact protection has been a hot topic in the hand protection space all year due to the roll-out and adaptation of the new American National Standard for Performance and Classification for Impact-Resistant Gl…
READ MORE10 Things To Consider When Selecting A Hard Hat
If the hard hat is comfortable for the worker, it is more likely to remain on the workers head. The seasoned worker who has been on the worksite longer is accustomed to wearing a hard hat for long du…
READ MOREDisposable Gloves for Heavy-Duty Industrial Jobs?
Many current studies related to the global safety market will highlight how disposable gloves account for a growing share of glove consumption. One research document boldly professes that "disposable gl…
READ MORENoise Induced Hearing Loss Is 100% Preventable. With The Correct PPE.
It seems like every other article on hearing protection is talking about Noise Induced Hearing Loss. And for good reason; Noise Induced Hearing Loss, or NIHL as it’s commonly referred to, is a "s…
READ MOREProtective Sleeve Buyers Guide
When it comes to arm protection, you don't have to settle for what's already out there. Each work environment, task, and person provides a different set of variables that affect the type of protection re…
READ MORECut Protection Fit for a Knight
Cut protection gloves have undergone a wide array of changes over the years. Original cut protection goes back centuries when metal armor and chainmail were used for protection. This was an effective to…
READ MORE